Skip to main content

The EU Emissions Trading System is an Opportunity for Industrial Competitiveness

Contextualisation Climate policy EU Industry
Thursday, 16.07.2026
On 17 July, the European Commission will present its proposal for reforming the ETS. Early drafts suggest a weakening of the system. That would be the wrong path. An analysis.

What the EU Emissions Trading System is and how it works

The EU Emissions Trading System (ETS) is the central market-based instrument for greening the European economy. It caps CO2 emissions and allows companies to trade a number of emission allowances that decreases every year. This puts a price on emissions and gives companies an incentive to avoid them.

Since 2005, the ETS has covered the energy and industrial sectors. And it works: between 2005 and 2024, emissions covered by the ETS fell by 51 percent across the EU, significantly more than total EU emissions over the same period.

What the upcoming ETS reform is about

On 17 July, the European Commission will present its ETS reform. One reason is the need to align the system with the newly adopted EU climate target for 2040. At the same time, the system is under political pressure: several member states and industry players, from steel to chemicals, are calling for relief in light of high CO2 costs. The key point of contention is whether free allowances should be handed out for longer than currently planned, as industry is demanding. Yet this is precisely what would noticeably weaken the ETS’s impact.

A second, less discussed element of the proposal points in the opposite direction. The Commission apparently intends, for the first time, to require that a minimum share of revenues be earmarked for decarbonisation measures within the ETS sectors themselves. Until now, member states have been largely free to decide how to use their revenues. For the greening of industry, this would certainly be a step forward.

Why weakening the ETS solves no problems

Although industry has been generously supplied with free allowances for years, industrial emissions fell by less than nine percent between 2013 and 2022, far below the nearly 30 percent decline in the more strictly regulated energy sector.

In general, studies show that the ETS has had only limited effects on corporate profitability and employment. At the macroeconomic level, too, the effects on economic output and inflation have remained marginal.

For certain regions and sectors, however, the burdens are real: carbon-intensive economies in Central and Eastern Europe are under considerably greater pressure. This is exactly why instruments such as the EU Modernisation Fund and the Just Transition Fund are important.

There are also companies that are already investing in their green transition but whose technical transformation is still underway, and which therefore feel disadvantaged by the ETS. Voestalpine, for example, justifies its call for extended free allowances by arguing that it cannot produce with low emissions as long as there is no infrastructure for hydrogen supply. Such cases require individual solutions, but they are no argument for weakening the entire system.

How the ETS can strengthen industrial competitiveness

If the EU weakens the ETS, it will not only undermine an instrument that has demonstrably worked since 2005. It will also squander enormous potential for the competitiveness of Europe’s struggling industry: the potential that lies in the ETS when it is understood not only as “cap-and-trade” but also as “cap-and-invest”.

The figures show how great this potential is. Since 2013, the ETS has generated more than 245 billion euros in auction revenues. In 2024 alone, revenues amounted to 39 billion euros, of which more than 24 billion euros went to member states. The remainder went at EU level to the Innovation Fund, the Modernisation Fund and the Recovery and Resilience Facility. In 2025, Austria collected a total of around 1.7 billion euros from the European ETS and national carbon pricing.

So far, however, this potential has been used only insufficiently. According to a Commission report, member states were expected to spend around 30.9 billion euros of their ETS revenues on climate and energy purposes in 2023, yet only 0.7 billion euros of that went specifically into industrial decarbonisation. This is exactly where the proposed mandatory earmarking comes in.

Rather than relying solely on the market price signal, ETS revenues should therefore be invested in the green transition in a more targeted and binding way than before, instead of being undermined by the indiscriminate allocation of free allowances. In this way, the ETS can not only provide planning certainty for companies but also become an accelerator of freedom, one that makes our economy independent of oil and gas, high energy costs and the risk of future price shocks more quickly. And it can make Europe competitive in the growing global market for clean future technologies and climate-neutral production.